How to optimize VAT. Tax optimization: acceptable ways to optimize VAT
What are the ways to optimize VAT in 2019? Which schemes are legal and which are not. What methods and schemes are there, and how to apply them for different organizations.
Dear readers! The article talks about typical ways to resolve legal issues, but each case is individual. If you want to know how solve exactly your problem- contact a consultant:
APPLICATIONS AND CALLS ARE ACCEPTED 24/7 and 7 days a week.
It's fast and FOR FREE!
Tax legislation requires entrepreneurs to pay a large number of taxes. Therefore, many are looking for ways to slightly reduce their size or get a deferment.
Not all of them are legal, so tax authorities always check the activities of companies with particular care. However, there are methods that allow you to optimize taxes without violating the law.
What you need to know
It is known that every modern businessman is required to pay a huge amount of taxes. And their optimization allows entrepreneurs to save significantly.
In 2019, many changes were made to the Tax Code. This also applies to paying taxes such as VAT. For example, it allows taxpayers to make payments not on the 20th, but on the 25th.
If VAT exemption applies, entrepreneurs can take advantage of the deferment. Another innovation for 2019 is provision in electronic form.
This innovation is regulated by the Tax Code (, 174). In addition, if the declaration is submitted in paper form, it will not be considered submitted.
This also applies to tax agents, and not just taxpayers themselves. To ensure that optimization does not violate the law, you should know:
To achieve a significant result from optimization, it is necessary to make it comprehensive. Otherwise, the effect of the company paying attention to only one transaction will be minimal.
The main thing is to have an experienced specialist who was able to do everything without violating Russian legislation. If you need to create an intermediary company for optimization, then you must:
- separate room;
- materials and funds in a bank account;
- personnel working in the new company;
- all activities must be documented.
A rate of 10% is used for the sale of certain types of printed publications, children's goods, imported medicines and livestock.
It is also taken into account for domestic air transport. VAT of 18% applies to all other cases. Rates of 10/110% and 18/118% are paid if an advance payment has been made for the goods.
Legal regulation
Everything related to taxation is regulated by the Tax Code of the Russian Federation, and the letter of the Ministry of Finance of Russia dated March 26, 2012 No. 03-07-05/08.
Value added tax optimization methods
There are several such methods. But most often taxpayers use the following methods:
Options | This is the name for contracts in which the person who bought the option can at any time refuse the rights to it. The sale of options is not subject to value added tax () |
Some companies sell their property to pay off their debt. But it is subject to VAT. Therefore, this deal is replaced with another. For this purpose, another company is created, and the funds invested in it are considered authorized capital. VAT is not paid on them | |
Deposit | In this case, the company formalizes the advance as a deposit, for which it is drawn up. It is not taxed |
Transport Cost Management | This optimization method allows an entrepreneur to reduce VAT by 10%. For this purpose, the goods can be delivered by the seller’s transport or |
Loan | The buyer pays for the goods using a loan. Then he receives it from the seller. Next, a netting agreement is drawn up. But tax authorities often consider such a scheme as illegal. |
What is the purpose of the event
All methods of optimizing value added tax allow taxpayers not only to reduce the amount of payments, but also to receive a deferment. To do this, just use the appropriate method.
VAT optimization schemes
The most popular legal schemes that entrepreneurs use to reduce VAT are registration, registration of a deposit, replacement of a purchase and sale agreement and management of transport costs.
But it is important to know that when borrowing, you must ensure that the cost of the goods and the loan amount do not coincide. As well as the deadlines for sending cargo and signing documents.
Video: tax optimization
Otherwise, the tax authorities may decide that this scheme was invented on purpose and is illegal. In the case where the advance is formalized as a deposit, the tax is paid only after the specified services are provided.
This method is often used in the construction industry. In addition to these schemes, there are several more:
Receipt of goods | The company has the right to withhold for some time the transfer of funds from the “Capital investments in non-current assets” account to the “Fixed Assets” account. Then VAT can be deducted |
Disadvantages in | If there are any shortcomings in the document from the supplier, VAT may not be deducted. Naturally, until the supplier eliminates the errors in the invoice |
Deadlines for receiving an invoice | The amount of VAT to be deducted is accepted upon receipt of this document. Therefore, receipt of an invoice can be arranged at a later date. |
It should be issued if the cost of services or goods will not change. A document is drawn up in any form in which the bill of exchange details must be indicated. Funds will be transferred through it as payment for goods or services. This money is not subject to taxation () | |
Clarifications in the declaration | There are situations when large amounts of funds are expected to be received at the end of the reporting month, and the input VAT will increase the following month. This means that these receipts may not be taken into account in the declaration. In the declaration for the next month, it is necessary to recalculate the VAT and late fees. This method is convenient when a company submits monthly declarations, as it allows it not to withdraw funds from the company’s turnover. Paying a small penalty prevents the tax authorities from regarding this scheme as fraudulent. |
In addition, a company may have its own individual VAT optimization schemes. The fact is that some well-known schemes can greatly harm a company. Therefore, entrepreneurs have to create their own unique methods.
Using the example of an organization
How to optimize VAT in 2019 in a company? You can consider one of the optimization schemes using an example.
Let’s say that the Ogonyok company needs to sell goods worth 20 thousand rubles. At the same time, the company uses the general taxation system, which means VAT will be 18%.
The seller also requires the buyer to make an advance payment in the amount of 4,720 rubles. VAT is also taken into account. If the transaction goes through on the grounds, then the company will have to pay VAT in the amount of 720 thousand rubles.
And the entire amount of VAT will be 3 thousand 600 rubles. If you use an option scheme, both parties can set a certain price for the product.
For example, 18 thousand rubles. They conclude a contract under which the seller transfers a so-called premium of 4 thousand rubles.
This money is not subject to VAT. The tax will have to be paid in the amount of:
3 thousand 240 rubles (18 thousand rubles * 18%)
The savings for the selling company will be 720 thousand rubles.
Features by type of activity of the enterprise
There are many ways to optimize VAT, but it all depends on the company’s activities. Trading companies can reduce tax by switching to a simplified tax system or creating (legally) secondary companies.
For wholesale trade
It should be taken into account that optimization is possible in 2 cases:
- if there are buyers who do not need VAT deductions;
- if buyers pay tax but resell goods to those who do not pay.
In the first case, the payers are individuals or companies using, as well as the simplified tax system. Insurance companies, government agencies and banks do not need it.
In the second case, the buyer may be a large store that pays VAT, but its customers do not. All you need to do is create a new company through the simplified tax system and use it to sell goods without VAT.
In production
Tax optimization of VAT in production includes several schemes. For example, you can use an enterprise that is a VAT exemption.
This is possible if the company's authorized capital consists of funds contributed by a public organization of disabled people.
Another way to optimize tax payment is to divide the load between several enterprises. One of them will be the main one, and the second should perform an auxiliary function.
The result of such a scheme will be that one company will produce products, the price of which already includes VAT. And in the second company - those goods that are sold without the allocation of taxes.
In auxiliary production, products can be produced independently, or with the help of the main company. In any case, thanks to the scheme, material costs of the main production will increase, and other costs will decrease.
The second enterprise will have everything the other way around. Based on this, the tax amount for the VAT payer is reduced due to its increase for the non-payer.
To achieve maximum savings, it is necessary to increase the amount of material costs at the main enterprise, and at the second - the volume of production.
1821
February 16, 2018 Companies have both VAT-taxable and non-taxable transactions. In the first case, the company has the right to claim input VAT for deduction. In the second, take into account the input tax in the cost of the product (work, service). But there are costs that apply simultaneously to all operations, and cannot be directly divided between activities. For such expenses it is necessary to divide the input VAT using the calculation method. Find out how to increase the amount of VAT deductible and reduce it in expenses and what to do if the markup differs by type of activity. 2314
December 28, 2017 The seller can change the price of the transaction by including VAT on top of the price, even when the transaction has already been completed. Look at what language in the contract will help avoid this. 11505
How to reduce taxes when buying and selling real estate
December 20, 2017 We learned six tax burden optimization schemes that companies use when buying and selling real estate. See which method is right for you and how to reduce the risks of tax claims when implementing the chosen scheme. 28247
Detailed income will increase VAT deduction
November 10, 2016 In addition to taxable activities, the company conducts non-taxable activities: it sells scrap metal without charging VAT. Costs attributable to non-taxable transactions exceeded 5 percent of all costs. Referring to this, officials said: only part of the input VAT is deducted. The organization agreed with this statement, but pointed out: the Federal Tax Service incorrectly determines the VAT deduction. 5042
Dangerous scheme: how to save company taxes
January 19, 2018 The citizen first worked for a company, then opened an individual entrepreneur and began retailing the products of her former employer. Tax officials considered this a tax scheme and assessed additional taxes, penalties and fines on the company. Read the article about the taxpayer's arguments that refuted the controllers' accusations.
15 methods to detect that a company is illegally cashing out money
July 12, 2016 The ways in which cash is used and the methods used to obtain it can be criminal. Solving such crimes very often depends on proving the fact of cashing out. At the same time, entrepreneurs, business owners, and top managers have a vague idea of methods for identifying facts of cashing out. They do not know how evidence is collected as part of operational investigative activities.
“Cash out”, “fly-by-night” and other popular services of “black” tax optimizers
December 10, 2015 PNP magazine decided to find out what services tax optimizers offer on the “black” market. During the investigation, the editorial staff found out how much cash withdrawal costs in various regions of Russia, how optimizers process fictitious payments, and what services a “special payroll company” provides.
How tax authorities uncovered a scheme involving a loan and subsequent liquidation of the lender
February 2, 2018 Why the scheme failed: the new creditor of the borrowing company did not try to collect the debt. In addition, he did not accrue interest on the agreement of assignment of the right of claim. The taxpayer did not provide the tax authorities with a novation agreement, which would confirm that the loan obligation is being converted into a bill of exchange.
Why tax schemes don't work
January 12, 2018 Even the slightest oversight can ruin a tax scheme. Make sure to consider all risks.
The court recognized cash gifts as wages
December 15, 2017 The company gave cash gifts to employees. Not every month, but often: eight times in 2013, seven in 2014. Why the court reclassified them as wages, read the article.
February 20, 2018 This article was removed from the website of the journal “Practical Tax Planning”
How to take into account less VAT in the value of an asset
February 16, 2018 Companies have both VAT-taxable and non-taxable transactions. In the first case, the company has the right to claim input VAT for deduction. In the second, take into account the input tax in the cost of the product (work, service). But there are costs that apply simultaneously to all operations, and cannot be directly divided between activities. For such expenses it is necessary to divide the input VAT using the calculation method. Find out how to increase the amount of VAT deductible and reduce it in expenses and what to do if the markup differs by type of activity.
What language should be included in the contract to prevent the seller from demanding VAT on top of the price?
December 28, 2017 The seller can change the price of the transaction by including VAT on top of the price, even when the transaction has already been completed. Look at what language in the contract will help avoid this.
How to save on taxes with the help of an individual entrepreneur. Overview of circuits
February 20, 2018 This article was removed from the website of the journal “Practical Tax Planning”
Property Tax Scheme - with sale back of movable asset
On May 25, 2016, the Company sold production equipment to an associate and bought it back within a short period of time. Comptrollers accused the company of not paying property taxes. The tax avoidance scheme was aimed at removing movable assets from property tax. The company went to court. How the dispute ended, read in the article (resolution of the Volga-Vyatka District Autonomous District Court dated 03/09/16 No. F01-262/2016).
Optimization of the tax burden – without errors
May 17, 2016 Tax planning errors are fraught with serious additional charges, and sometimes even bankruptcy of the company. Therefore, it is important to do everything possible to exclude them.
It’s realistic to fire with severance pay and then hire
March 12, 2018 Dismissal by agreement of the parties relieves the employee of personal income tax on severance pay amounts, and the company takes these payments into account in tax expenses and does not pay insurance premiums. This scheme is usually used to profitably transfer the company's income to the owner-director. However, this tax-free method of paying income attracts the attention of tax authorities. The court suggested how to avoid claims from inspectors.
January 17, 2018 The Tax Code lists only the elements of taxation. There are no conditions for the tax burden or the share of deductions. However, in practice, after taxpayers have settled with the budget, inspectors may ask the question: “Why is it so little?” Find out what metrics really matter and how to lower tax inspectors' expectations.
How inspectors turn tax claims into criminal ones
December 14, 2017 To adjust the amount of tax evasion to a criminal offense, inspectors resort to many tricks and interpretations. As a result, the threshold amounts may change beyond recognition. How to avoid negative consequences, read the article.
The company took into account in other expenses the cost of work on adapting the program. What did the court decide?
December 12, 2017 Tax inspectors accepted the adaptation of the program as a new intangible object and assessed additional taxes and penalties to the company in the total amount of 23.7 million rubles. The organization decided to challenge the tax authorities’ decision. Read the article to see whose side the court took.
There is nothing strange or unusual in the desire of every business entity to minimize contributions to the budget. Among all receipts, y is the second largest in quantity. VAT optimization is carried out everywhere, and for this purpose certain methods and schemes are used that help to do this legally.
Is it possible to reduce VAT?
In accordance with the norms established by law, VAT is calculated:
- From the amount of revenue received from the shipment of items subject to taxation.
- From advance payments (receipts as prepayments).
The tax rate and application procedure are regulated by Art. 164 Tax Code of the Russian Federation. In 2017, for most enterprises it remained unchanged at 18%. How can I reduce the VAT payable by the amount of tax indicated by suppliers in the invoice? It is most difficult to optimize expenses for this tax. But there are ways. There are two of them:
- Reduce implementation.
- Increase deductions.
The only problem is to do it correctly. Otherwise - additional VAT charges, fines and penalties, and even more significant sanctions. In other words, by approaching the matter wisely, you can significantly reduce the amount of tax without breaking the law.
If you do not use VAT optimization methods correctly, you can be caught by the tax authorities and held accountable. It is better when a qualified accountant does this.
How to do it
There are ways to legally reduce VAT. There are several of them. Everyone will help to legally reduce your tax burden.
Exemption from VAT
Any business entity has the right to be exempt from VAT subject to the following mandatory requirements:
- It carries out operations on the Russian market.
- The goods sold are not classified as excisable.
- Over the course of 3 months, the revenue volume did not amount to two million rubles (excluding VAT).
A petition submitted to the Federal Tax Service is valid for a year. Having received the exemption of the organization (or), you will no longer have to charge VAT and pay it, maintain books of purchases and sales (Article 145 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). She is exempt from submitting a tax return. But at the same time, the rights to tax deductions for VAT are lost, and the “input” tax is now included in the price of a unit of goods (services).
Agency agreement instead of purchase and sale
The seller, as an agent, calculates the tax base not from the sales amount, but from the amount of remuneration, which is reflected in the contract. True, the agency agreement itself must be drawn up correctly so that no one can reclassify it as a supply agreement.
Advance (bill or deposit)
Typically, advance payments must be taxable. But it is quite possible to save yourself from unnecessary payments if you draw up an agreement with the buyer.
The options for replacing the advance payment are as follows:
- Replacing an advance with a cash loan. Here you need to keep in mind the following: an agreement is drawn up under which the buyer provides a loan in an amount comparable to the cost of delivery; money received by the supplier is not subject to VAT; the goods are shipped in accordance with the supply agreement; The completion of the transaction is the act of offset. And try to avoid terms in the agreement that could give tax authorities the right to charge additional VAT, and with it significant fines.
- Agreement on deposit. If the main activity is manufacturing or construction, this option is quite suitable. After all, they sometimes have to use the advance payment transferred by the buyer for the purchase of materials and raw materials. It will be necessary to draw up an annex to the contract in the form of a deposit agreement. All documents must be completed correctly. And then there is no need to pay VAT on this amount.
- Advance on a bill. Rarely used, but absolutely legal and, moreover, devoid of any pitfalls. In this case, the supplier, according to the act, transfers his own bill of exchange to the buyer, in payment of which the latter transfers the corresponding amount to the drawer. This advance payment is not considered and is not subject to tax. Upon shipment, the parties read out their mutual requirements in an act.
All of the above methods and tools for reducing VAT are legal, and by using them wisely, the taxpayer reduces his expenses.
VAT optimization depends on tax planning. The essence of optimization is to increase the company's cash flows by minimizing tax payments in accordance with current legislation. There are ways of tax optimization of VAT permitted by law, various schemes and methods, the solution of which can be found for any organization.
The essence of tax optimization is to minimize tax payments and avoid penalties. This can be achieved through correct and timely payment of taxes.
The Tax Code of the Russian Federation presents the taxpayer with a choice depending on the specific economic activity. For example:
- A business entity can choose the tax payment option that seems optimal to it.
- If possible, the law allows you to choose a type of economic activity that is not taxed under Article 149.
- Another option for reducing tax payments is to carry out export operations:
Get 267 video lessons on 1C for free:
The options for optimizing VAT tax payments described above cannot be subject to claims from tax authorities; they can be interpreted as competent planning of business activities, which allows achieving tax savings with the least risk.
The formation of profit centers in those entities that have a reduced tax burden also has a positive effect on the amount of payments. This method is considered the most popular and safest among Russian entrepreneurs.
Factors influencing VAT optimization
To assess the amount of VAT optimization, the following factors must be taken into account:
- Who is the counterparty - a resident of the Russian Federation / non-resident, does it have benefits, individual entrepreneur / legal entity;
- Relations between the parties;
- Transfer of ownership of products or goods.
Before you begin to assess the possibility of optimizing the amount of VAT, you need to carefully analyze all the features of concluding contracts. To do this, it is best to use the balance sheet method of tax planning.
How to reduce your tax burden
Today there are a huge number of methods that can reduce the tax burden on an organization. It should be immediately noted that some of them are universal, while others are suitable only in certain situations. The most common ways to optimize tax payments are:
- Method of changing the type of activity.
- Method of changing the tax subject.
- Method of replacing tax jurisdiction.
- Optimization method through contractual relations.
- Method of using benefits and exemptions.
- A method of making policy that makes maximum use of the opportunities provided by law.
Also among the special schemes to reduce the VAT rate are:
- Relationship replacement method.
- Tax payment deferment method.
- Relationship separation method.
- Method of direct reduction of the taxable object:
Optimization of VAT using the example of an organization
Many organizations mistakenly believe that VAT can only be optimized through the interaction of several organizations with different tax regimes. Because of this, legal entities often register several companies, the main one of which acts as an intermediary. She is engaged in purchasing goods from the manufacturer. After that, she resells the product and receives her commission. Thus, the level of VAT, which applies only to this remuneration, is reduced.
Also, one organization with a traditional taxation regime can sell its goods to another company that operates on the basis of a simplified taxation system. Income from the sale of this product is received only by those companies that sell it at the market price. Despite making a profit, they will pay less value added tax.
It should be taken into account that such schemes for optimizing VAT at enterprises always attract a lot of attention from the tax authorities. It is important that company employees have an accurate legal address and conduct business activities.
In this article we will take a closer look at the topic of VAT payment. What important amendments to the law were adopted in 2015? What schemes are most popular among Russian companies? Read on for step-by-step and accessible information about this.
In this article you will read:
- What changes have been made to the VAT law in 2015?
- What punishment is provided for illegal VAT optimization schemes?
- What to do if you are faced with an audit regarding an illegal VAT refund
- What methods of VAT optimization are currently the most secure?
What has changed with VAT in 2015
In accordance with the amendments to clause 8 of Art. 145 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation, when using the exemption not from the 1st month of the quarter, the restored tax may be reflected in the last declaration. The deadlines for submitting the declaration and paying the tax were postponed to the 25th (Article 174 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation).
Check your partners urgently!
Do you know that When checking, tax authorities can cling to any suspicious fact about the counterparty? Therefore, it is very important to check those with whom you work. Today, you can receive free information about your partner’s past inspections, and most importantly, receive a list of identified violations!
Taxpayers have the opportunity to shift the deadlines for paying VAT by 5 days. In particular, it will be necessary to pay the tax no later than January 26, February 25 and March 25, 2015 (taking into account clause 1 of Article 174, clause 7 of Article 6.1 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation).
By changing the VAT restoration period when using the exemption not from the beginning of the year, legislators provided the opportunity to obtain a certain deferment from paying the restored tax. In particular, entrepreneurs and companies that received an exemption from April 1 will have to transfer the restored VAT no later than April 27, May 25 and June 25. By obtaining an exemption, it becomes possible to postpone the deadline for paying the restored VAT to July 27, August 25 and September 25. After all, Article 174 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation does not contain any clauses on changing the procedure for paying tax when receiving an exemption.
It is worth noting that the tax authorities provide the opportunity to change the tax period, but only during the reorganization of the company (clause 4 of article 55 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). This rule will not apply in case of release. At the same time, the entrepreneur or company, upon exemption of receipt, remains a taxpayer. Consequently, the tax period does not end for them.
VAT optimization: current schemes for 2015
In addition to the well-known legal schemes for optimizing VAT, proper execution of primary documents also deserves attention.
1) Applying for a loan. The buyer provides the seller with a loan in the amount of the cost of the goods. Next, a supply contract is drawn up without prepayment. According to this agreement, the buyer is provided with the goods. To complete the transaction, the 3rd agreement is drawn up - offset. In accordance with this agreement, the loan will be offset against payment for the goods supplied.
Disadvantages of this method: this transaction may be classified by the tax authorities as a tax evasion scheme. Therefore, the following conditions are important:
– it is necessary to carefully think through and prescribe the purpose of receiving a loan, and not a logical advance;
– make sure that there is no correspondence between every penny of the loan amount and the cost of the goods;
– make sure that the days of shipment of the goods, the signing of the mutual settlement agreement, and the terms of the return of the debt agreement do not coincide.
2) Execution of a written agreement on the deposit. The deposit is not an object of taxation. Consequently, the advance can be documented as a deposit, for which a written agreement will be concluded. Legally, the seller may not include the amount of this deposit in the tax base before the actual provision of services or shipment of goods.
This method is relevant for optimization in the construction industry. It is not uncommon here to provide an advance for the purchase of materials purchased in parts. As a result, VAT is required to be paid at the end of the quarters, and there are also no deductions because subcontractor services and materials have not been accepted in full. Therefore, it is better to immediately draw up an agreement on a deposit for the purchase of materials, with payment of tax upon the conclusion of a certificate of completion of work, when all deductions and costs are taken into account.
3) Establishing the transfer of ownership of the goods. This act is called the transfer of rights of implementation (clause 1 of Article 39 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation). Sales agreements provide for the possibility of stipulating a step-by-step transfer of ownership of goods, ultimately benefiting from a deferment of VAT payment.
4) Replacement of the purchase and sale agreement with an agency agreement. If the supplier is not a VAT payer, therefore, the seller has no VAT deductions. In this case, you will need to pay tax on the full cost of goods sold. The seller has the opportunity to conclude an agency agreement or a commission agreement using a reverse or direct agency scheme for VAT optimization. The transfer of goods occurs from the supplier to the seller for a commission. The seller sells the goods at his own markup, paying the cost of the goods to the supplier under the concluded agreement.
Tax authorities did not prove that the company entered into agency agreements in order to obtain tax benefits
Olga Eremina, lawyer at Hannes Snellman, Moscow
The tax inspectorate brought the company to justice in accordance with Art. 122 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation for incomplete payment of VAT. Tax inspectors considered that agency agreements were concluded by the company only for the sake of unjustified tax benefits. Nevertheless, the tax authorities lost in the trial. The court established the fact that the agent compiled quarterly reports indicating the amounts of remuneration that were received from customers, as well as the amounts that were transferred to the seller, and the amounts of remuneration for agency services.
The fact of execution of agency agreements by all participants in the transaction was confirmed. The court noted that the inspectors did not prove that the agent’s actions were aimed solely at obtaining tax benefits. Consequently, the court ruled that the tax authorities’ decision to hold the taxpayer accountable was unlawful (resolution of the Federal Antimonopoly Service of the West Siberian District dated November 10, 2008 No. F04-6892/2008 (15713-A46-41) in case No. A46-2364/2008).
5) By managing transportation costs. This VAT optimization method is applicable for payers working at a reduced tax rate of 10%. It is used in 2 types:
– upon delivery of goods by the seller’s transport;
– when applying for the services of a transport company.
In the first case: VAT on transport services is 18% in any case (clause 1 of Article 153 of the Tax Code of the Russian Federation), but if they are shown separately in the invoice, payment of tax at the rate will be required.
The solution in such a situation would be to include these services in the total cost of the goods. When calculating the price or calculation, there is no need to include “transport” costs as a separate item - the tax authorities will easily calculate the amount from which the arrears are required to be paid. They can be included in sales costs without decoding. In this case, isolating the cost of transport services will be practically impossible.
The second case involves the benefit that the goods are sold by the seller at a VAT rate of 10%, and VAT deductions from the services of a transport organization are accepted at a rate of 18%.
6) Other legitimate optimization schemes in the enterprise:
1. Bill advance. If the price of the goods is known in advance and will not change, the seller has the option of providing the buyer with his own bill of exchange. The transfer is documented in the form of an act drawn up in any form, indicating the details of the bill. The money is transferred by the buyer on a bill of exchange, which will not become an advance, and is subject to taxation. After the goods have been shipped, an agreement on the offset of mutual claims is drawn up, where the previously shipped goods will represent payment on the bill of exchange.
2. Updated declaration. If a situation arises that at the end of the reporting month there are large revenue receipts, and in the next month there will be a significant receipt of input VAT, a VAT return can be submitted to the tax office without taking into account the amount of this receipt. When submitting a declaration for the next month, reflecting these deductions, it is necessary to recalculate the VAT for the previous month, pay a penalty for late VAT, and submit an updated declaration. The penalty will be small, and the company will have the opportunity not to withdraw funds from circulation. This method is suitable for those who file a declaration and pay VAT on a monthly basis, since the inspector only has a month to identify the fact that an incorrect declaration has been filed. After the company independently “identifies the error” and pays all penalties, tax inspectors will no longer have the opportunity to bring charges and penalties.
It happens that it is necessary to postpone not the moment of payment of VAT, but the moment of obtaining the right to submit tax for deduction
Igor Bogomolov, head of the project work department of the tax and legal department of the management company “Independent Directors”, Moscow
There may be situations when it is necessary to postpone not the moment of payment of VAT to the budget, but the moment of obtaining the right to claim this tax for deduction. This will be possible, in particular, when the company has exceeded the deduction standards recommended by the tax inspectorates. The tax authorities themselves recommend that many companies transfer part of their deductions in order to avoid unnecessary doubts during the audit. This advice about the transfer is given directly by the inspector, so in the next period, most likely, he will accept the company’s declaration with the transferred deduction.
In this situation, you can use the following methods to transfer deductions:
1. Document the late invoice. According to the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation, in this case, the right to present the amount of VAT for deduction arises not during the period of the transaction, but during the period of receipt of the invoice. Courts usually take a similar position.
2. Finding flaws in the invoice provided by the supplier. If such deficiencies are identified, you have the right not to deduct VAT. The purchasing company has the right to claim the amount of VAT for deduction only after the buyer has made corrections to the invoice.
3. Postpone posting of goods. It is possible to delay the transfer of fixed assets from account 08 “Capital investments in non-current assets” to account 01 “Fixed assets”. The property in this period is classified as “Capitalized”, the company has the right to accept VAT for deduction.
It is important to take into account that if the documents confirming the legality of the transfer of deductions from the company are not properly executed, after 2-3 years you may encounter serious problems during an on-site tax audit. Practice confirms the difficulty of defending your position in court.
10 tips for taxpayers to avoid breaking the law
1. Any business model that provides relief from the tax burden must be comprehensively and preliminary assessed for the presence of tax risks.2. Transactions concluded should not be of a sham nature; there must be a convincingly formed business goal.
3. It is necessary to have a competent justification for the pricing policy used, which does not contradict the provisions of Art. 40 Tax Code of the Russian Federation.
4. Transaction prices must be motivated with foreign intermediaries, corresponding to the market level.
5. Everything carried out within the group of companies should not look artificial or imaginary. It is necessary that any transaction clearly fits into the general logic of the holding’s business process.
6. The preparation of documents that confirm the reality and economic justification of costs deserves due attention.
7. It is worth avoiding the interdependence of parties to transactions during tax planning.
8. When selecting new counterparties, evidence of due diligence must be documented.
9. It is better to refuse cooperation with “gray” optimizers and unreliable partners.
10. During the implementation of the VAT optimization scheme, it will be useful to obtain a written explanation from the tax office about its legality and feasibility.
What is the penalty for illegal VAT refund?
Almost everyone knows that illegal VAT refunds result in criminal liability. But how does it manifest itself, what consequences are possible? To answer this question, it is necessary to correctly qualify a specific crime by identifying the appropriate article of the Criminal Code, according to which one can judge the possible consequences.
- Current assets of an enterprise: concept, management and analysis
Many believe that illegal VAT refund is a tax crime, which is punishable under Article 199 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation - tax evasion by an organization. The maximum consequence, according to part 1 of this article, involves imprisonment for up to two years. The second part of the article (in case of non-payment of tax on an especially large scale or by a group of persons) – up to 6 years. But according to established judicial practice, illegal VAT refunds are classified as fraud in accordance with Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation.
Fraud carries a more severe penalty. In particular, according to Part 4 of Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation (this is what is usually applied), the punishment is imprisonment for up to 10 years with a fine of up to 1 million rubles.
If the illegality of the VAT refund is revealed after a positive decision on the VAT refund and the receipt of funds into the organization’s current account from the treasury, the crime will be considered completed. If the money is not transferred, including due to refusal of VAT refund, the actions will be qualified as an attempt. Since the state did not face real damage during the assassination attempt, one can count on less serious punishments, but they still turn out to be not conditional, but real.
How tax authorities can check the validity of a VAT refund
The main task of the tax authorities is to prove the fictitiousness of the transactions being carried out. When checking the legality of VAT refunds, tax officials can take a number of measures:
– request from tax inspectorates information about open accounts, VAT paid for the reporting and past periods, as well as information on participants, founders and other data;
– obtaining information from banks on the movement of funds in current accounts;
- Tax audit: how to behave competently if inspectors come
– interrogation of accountants, directors and other employees of organizations, as well as in the chain of transactions for which VAT was to be paid;
– carrying out inspections of warehouses, construction sites, premises to check the availability of constructed buildings and purchased products;
– sending requests for the provision of documentation to confirm the actual conduct of transactions - including invoices, contracts, primary documents of warehouse, accounting and production records.
What facts indicate the illegality of VAT payment?
Signs of fictitious companies (one-day companies):
– upon recent registration of a legal entity, “for a transaction”;
– the company is registered at mass addresses;
– with a small staff;
– the company is actually absent from its location;
– there are no costs for maintaining the office, purchasing office equipment, and office supplies.
Signs of nominee directors:
– a person is en masse a founder or director of other legal entities;
– during interrogation by the tax authorities, and usually by law enforcement agencies, a person cannot answer basic questions that the manager needs to know;
– the director admits during interrogation that he is a figurehead;
– use of a citizen’s documents without his knowledge;
Signs of fictitious transactions:
– forged signatures were detected in the documents;
– the persons on whose behalf the signatures were placed do not confirm their authenticity;
– there is no actual crossing of goods into the Russian Federation border;
– there is no real movement of goods, there is no equipment in warehouses, the declared work was not carried out;
– there are no movements on accounts that are comparable to the provisions of the contracts.
Signs of a fictitious transaction:
– there is no economic feasibility in concluding a transaction;
– absence of VAT charges prior to reimbursement comparable to those declared in the period under review;
– interdependence between legal entities that participate in the transaction;
– the company (firms) was re-registered with another inspection immediately before the VAT refund;
- a combination of these factors, based on which one can conclude that there was intent only in creating formal grounds for tax refund, but without conducting real economic activity.
How can you protect yourself before criminal proceedings are initiated?
VAT refund cases involve the possibility of organizing a defense before initiating a criminal case. It should be understood that all materials collected as a result of a tax audit, if signs of illegal compensation appear, are transferred to law enforcement agencies, subsequently representing the basis of a criminal case.
Therefore, even at the verification stage, you need to be prepared to call the tax office to explain to the directors of the entire chain of legal entities whose testimony is important for the case. Analyze the questions voiced during interrogations in order to identify “weak” points in the taxpayer’s position, taking appropriate measures to strengthen it, providing additional explanations or documents.
- Service agreement: sample, typical mistakes
A decision to refuse a VAT refund, with the company being brought to tax liability, may become the basis for a criminal case. But when the arbitration court decides to cancel the decision to refuse VAT refund, criminal cases do not have a criminal-judicial perspective. A judicial act that has entered into force is binding on all government bodies and organizations, including law enforcement. Consequently, when challenging a refusal to refund VAT in an arbitration court, by winning this case, you will receive undoubted evidence of a legal VAT refund.
Before applying to arbitration, it is mandatory to go through the appropriate procedures for pre-trial dispute resolution, which are established by the Tax Code - with filing reasoned objections to the tax audit report, appealing the decision to refuse a VAT refund. These actions in themselves allow you to achieve the desired result, eliminating the grounds for a criminal case.
Of course, to draw up and challenge a decision, it is necessary to involve professional lawyers.
What to do if an audit has begun against you regarding illegal payment of VAT
Law enforcement officers are much more effective than tax officials, since they have a wider arsenal of possible actions. During a pre-investigation check and investigation of a criminal case, you need to be prepared for searches at the addresses of offices, warehouses and homes of the defendants. In the case of a major attempt to recover VAT, there is a possibility of establishing the IP addresses of bank-client connections, organizing wiretapping of telephone conversations, and viewing electronic correspondence.
The investigation involves interrogating persons who have already been interviewed during the tax audit, with the identification of other persons involved in the illegal VAT refund. Interrogations are designed to identify and confirm signs of illegality of VAT refunds, with proof of guilt on the part of a specific person.
At this stage, there is an aggravation of the contradictions between the defendants in the case, which law enforcement officers know how to competently and effectively play on. For ordinary executors-signatories, they will be asked to accept the position that “they did not understand what was happening”, did not know about the illegal VAT refund, but in return they must actively cooperate with the investigation. For the true beneficiaries, it is required that the previous testimony be preserved - for this it is necessary to competently organize a complex protection system, with control of the testimony of each person involved.
At the pre-investigation stage of a criminal investigation, it is imperative to involve a lawyer. During interrogations, he is able to prevent violations of the procedural rights of those being interrogated, insisting that the version voiced during the interrogation be recorded in the protocol, obtaining valuable information that a layperson will not be able to “hear.”
Information about authors and companies
Olga Eremina, lawyer Hannes Snellman company, Moscow. Graduated from the International Law Faculty of MGIMO. Engaged in consulting on tax law issues, including VAT refunds, taxation of foreign companies in the Russian Federation, assessment of tax risks when structuring transactions, including those involving the use of foreign jurisdictions. Represents the interests of client companies in arbitration courts in tax disputes and bankruptcy cases. Before joining Hannes Snellman, she worked as a tax consultant for a large trading holding. Hannes Snellman. Field of activity: legal services. Number of employees: 300. Main clients: Renaissance Capital, Electrolux, Nokia, Panasonic, Tikkurila.
Igor Bogomolov, head of the project work department of the tax and legal department of the management company “Independent Directors”, Moscow. "Independent Directors". Field of activity: legal and financial consulting. Number of personnel: 45. Main clients: CJSC Loko-Bank, OJSC Montazhspetsstroy, OJSC Russian Railways.